Robbery Florida

Robbery in Florida

Violent crime allegations in Florida are prosecuted aggressively and often carry life-changing consequences. Attorney Jason Goldsmith represents individuals charged with violent crimes throughout Florida. As a former Broward County prosecutor, he understands how these cases are screened, charged, negotiated, and tried—and how prosecutors evaluate evidence, credibility, and sentencing exposure.

Statutory authority commonly implicated for this topic includes: § 812.13 (Robbery), § 775.087 (weapon reclassification), Ch. 776 (use of force defenses where applicable). The exact statutes that apply depend on the facts, charging decisions, and any alleged enhancement factors such as a weapon, injury, or prior record.

Overview of the Charge

Robbery is a violent felony in Florida that involves taking property from a person or custody of another with the use of force, violence, assault, or putting the person in fear. Robbery is treated more seriously than theft because of the alleged force component, and sentencing exposure can be severe—especially if a weapon is alleged.

Statutory Elements the State Must Prove

The State generally must prove a taking of money or property from the person or custody of another, with intent to permanently or temporarily deprive, and that during the taking there was force, violence, assault, or fear. Identification and intent are frequently contested issues.

How These Cases Are Investigated

Robbery investigations often rely on surveillance video, eyewitness identification, fingerprints/DNA where available, and statements. Show-ups, lineups, and photo packs can create misidentification risks that require careful scrutiny.

Defense Themes and Case Strategy

Defense themes include mistaken identity, challenging whether force was used, disputing intent, challenging the reliability of identification procedures, and contesting confession evidence or unlawful searches.

Prosecutors often focus on identification evidence and video. A defense strategy frequently targets the reliability of eyewitness accounts, the completeness of video, and whether the alleged force element is truly satisfied.

Penalties, Enhancements, and Sentencing Exposure

Robbery carries significant prison exposure. If a firearm or weapon is alleged, enhancement statutes may increase felony degree and mandatory minimum exposure in certain scenarios. Sentencing depends on the facts, the felony classification, and the Criminal Punishment Code scoresheet.

Collateral Consequences

Robbery convictions can create severe collateral consequences, including professional barriers and firearm consequences. Because robbery is treated as a violent felony, the long-term impact can be substantial.

Questions People Ask About This Charge

What is the difference between robbery and theft in Florida?

Robbery involves taking property with force, violence, assault, or putting someone in fear during the taking. Theft generally does not involve that force component. That distinction is why robbery is punished more severely and treated as a violent felony. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

Can a robbery charge be based on 'fear' without physical injury?

Yes. The statute includes putting a person in fear. The State still must prove the fear element and the circumstances that created it during the taking. Disputes about what was said or done are common. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

How often do robbery cases involve misidentification?

Misidentification is a known risk factor, especially in stressful events, poor lighting, cross-racial identification issues, and brief encounters. A defense review should examine lineup procedures, suggestiveness, and any inconsistencies across witness descriptions. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

What if I never actually touched the person?

Physical contact is not always required if the State alleges fear or threats were used to accomplish the taking. The defense focuses on whether the legal elements are met and whether evidence supports the alleged force or fear. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

Is robbery a felony in Florida?

Yes. Robbery is a felony with significant exposure. The degree depends on whether a weapon is alleged and other circumstances. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

Can robbery be reduced to theft?

In some cases, yes—particularly where evidence of force or fear is weak. Negotiation depends on the evidence, the alleged victim’s account, and prosecutorial assessment of trial risk. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

How do weapons change robbery charges?

Weapon allegations can elevate classification and increase sentencing exposure. The defense may examine whether a weapon was actually used or displayed and whether the evidence supports an enhancement. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

How does a former prosecutor help in robbery cases?

Former prosecutorial experience helps anticipate how the State will present identification and video evidence and where to focus cross-examination, motions, and negotiation leverage. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

What should I do if police want an interview?

You have rights, including the right to remain silent and to counsel. Because statements can be decisive in robbery prosecutions, consult counsel before agreeing to interviews. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations. In practice, the facts that matter most often include what witnesses saw, what officers documented, what video captures, and whether the State can prove each legal element beyond a reasonable doubt. A defense strategy may focus on challenging identity, intent, credibility, admissibility, or the legality of searches and statements, depending on the allegations.

Statewide Florida Representation

Attorney Jason Goldsmith provides statewide representation for violent crime allegations and related felony charges across Florida. The main office is located in Broward County, Florida.

---

Legal Disclaimer: The information on this page is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this page does not create an attorney–client relationship. Every case is different and outcomes depend on specific facts, evidence, and applicable law. For advice about your situation, consult a qualified criminal defense attorney. Attorney Jason Goldsmith represents clients throughout the State of Florida. The main office is located in Broward County, Florida.